REPLY TO PETITION, LIST OF WITNESSES, MEMORANDUM OF APPEARANCE, LIST OF DOCUMENTS TO BE RELIED UPON, WITNESS STATEMENT ON OATH

REPLY TO PETITION

IN THE NATIONAL AND STATE HOUSES OF ELECTION TRIBUNAL
HOLDEN AT DELTA STATE

PETITION NO.: ……

RE- RUN ELECTION TO THE NATIONAL ASSEMBLY FOR ASABA NORTH SENATORIAL DISTRICT HELD ON SATURDAY THE 24TH OF MARCH 2011

BETWEEN:
  1. DR.VINCENT BROWN
  2. NATIONAL NIGERIAN PARTY……………………… PETITIONERS

AND
  1. CHIEF BEN OKAGBUE
  2. UNITY CONGRESS PARTY ……………………….... RESPONDENTS
  3. INEC

REPLY TO THE PETITION OF DR. VINCENT BROWN

  1. SAVE AND EXCEPT as is expressly admitted, the 1st Respondent denies every allegation of fact made in the petition as if same were set out and traversed seriatim.
  2. The 1st Respondent admits paragraph 2 of the petition.
  3. The 1st Respondent is not in the position to admit or deny paragraph 1 of the petition and put the petitioner to its strictest proof.
  4. The 1st Respondent denies paragraphs 3, 4, 5, 6…. of the petition.
  5. In reply to paragraphs 3, 4, 5, and 6 of the petition, the 1st Respondent states that the re-run election was in substantial compliance with the Electoral Act 2010 under a free and fair atmosphere.
  6. That the electoral materials were brought on time and there was no snatching of ballot boxes or any non-compliance been complained of.
  7. That the 1st Respondent was never indicted by the Economic and Financial Crimes Commission or any other Tribunal/Commission in 1995 or at any time whatsoever.
  8. That the 1st Respondent was never convicted by the High Court of Asaba in 1995 or any other Court for the offence of receiving stolen property or any other offence.
  9. That the 1st Respondent was qualified to contest the re-run elections.
  10. WHEREOF the 1st Respondent prays this Honourable Tribunal to dismiss the petition for it is frivolous and lacks merit.

ADDRESS FOR SERVICE:
  1. 1ST PETITIONER
    DR. BROWN
    ASABA, DELTA STATE
    OCCUPIER: DR. BROWN
  2. 2ND PETITIONER
    NATIONAL NIGERIAN PARTY
    NATIONAL HEADQUARTERS
    ABUJA
    OCCUPIER: NNP
  3. UNITY CONGRESS PARTY
  4. INDEPENDENT NATIONAL ELECTORAL COMMISSION
    MAITAMA ABUJA
    OCCUPIER: INEC

…………………………
Aniette
Group Eight Chambers
Whose address for service is
Group Eight.

Signed by …………..
Chief Ben Okagbue

SIGNED BEFORE ME THIS 27TH DAY OF MARCH 2011


………………………..……
SECRETARY

LIST OF WITNESSES

IN THE NATIONAL AND STATE HOUSES OF ELECTION TRIBUNAL
HOLDEN AT DELTA STATE

PETITION NO.: ……

RE- RUN ELECTION TO THE NATIONAL ASSEMBLY FOR ASABA NORTH SENATORIAL DISTRICT HELD ON SATURDAY THE 24TH OF MARCH 2011

BETWEEN:
  1. DR.VINCENT BROWN
  2. NATIONAL NIGERIAN PARTY……………………… PETITIONERS

AND
  1. CHIEF BEN OKAGBUE
  2. UNITY CONGRESS PARTY ……………………….... RESPONDENTS
  3. INEC

LIST OF WITNESSES
  1. Chief Ben Okagbue
  2. EmekaNwonsu

DATED THE 27TH DAY OF MARCH 2011


…………………
Aniette
Group Eight Chambers
Whose address for service is
Group Eight.





ADDRESS FOR SERVICE:
  1. 1ST Petitioner
    Dr. Brown
    Asaba, Delta State.
    Occupier: Dr. Brown
  2. 2ND Petitioner
    National Nigerian Party
    National Headquarters Abuja.
    Occupier: NNP
  3. Unity Congress Party
  4. Independent National Electoral Commission
    Maitama Abuja.
    Occupier: INEC

MEMORANDUM OF APPEARANCE

IN THE NATIONAL AND STATE HOUSES OF ELECTION TRIBUNAL
HOLDEN AT DELTA STATE

PETITION NO.: ……

RE- RUN ELECTION TO THE NATIONAL ASSEMBLY FOR ASABA NORTH SENATORIAL DISTRICT HELD ON SATURDAY THE 24TH OF MARCH 2011

BETWEEN:
  1. DR.VINCENT BROWN
  2. NATIONAL NIGERIAN PARTY……………………… PETITIONERS

AND
  1. CHIEF BEN OKAGBUE
  2. UNITY CONGRESS PARTY ……………………….... RESPONDENTS
  3. INEC

MEMORANDUM OF APPEARANCE

Please enter appearance for Chief Ben Okagbue sued as Respondent in this Petition.


DATED THE 27TH DAY OF MARCH 2011


…………………
Aniette
Group Eight Chambers
Whose address for service is
Group Eight.





LIST OF DOCUMENTS TO BE RELIED UPON

IN THE NATIONAL AND STATE HOUSES OF ELECTION TRIBUNAL
HOLDEN AT DELTA STATE

PETITION NO.: ……

RE- RUN ELECTION TO THE NATIONAL ASSEMBLY FOR ASABA NORTH SENATORIAL DISTRICT HELD ON SATURDAY THE 24TH OF MARCH 2011

BETWEEN:
  1. DR.VINCENT BROWN
  2. NATIONAL NIGERIAN PARTY……………………… PETITIONERS

AND
  1. CHIEF BEN OKAGBUE
  2. UNITY CONGRESS PARTY ……………………….... RESPONDENTS
  3. INEC

LIST OF COPIES OF DOCUMENTS TO BE RELIED UPON
  1. Election return certificate
  2. Video recordings of elections in all the Wards in the North Senatorial District of Asaba
  3. Copy of Agents records.

DATED THE 27TH DAY OF MARCH 2011


…………………
Aniette
Group Eight Chambers
Whose address for service is
Group Eight.





ADDRESS FOR SERVICE:
  1. 1ST Petitioner
    Dr. Brown
    Asaba, Delta State.
    Occupier: Dr. Brown
  2. 2ND Petitioner
    National Nigerian Party
    National Headquarters Abuja.
    Occupier: NNP
  3. Unity Congress Party
  4. Independent National Electoral Commission
    Maitama Abuja.
    Occupier: INEC

WITNESS STATEMENT ON OATH OF CHIEF BEN OKAGBUE

IN THE NATIONAL AND STATE HOUSES OF ELECTION TRIBUNAL
HOLDEN AT DELTA STATE

PETITION NO.: ……

RE- RUN ELECTION TO THE NATIONAL ASSEMBLY FOR ASABA NORTH SENATORIAL DISTRICT HELD ON SATURDAY THE 24TH OF MARCH 2011

BETWEEN:
  1. DR.VINCENT BROWN
  2. NATIONAL NIGERIAN PARTY……………………… PETITIONERS

AND
  1. CHIEF BEN OKAGBUE
  2. UNITY CONGRESS PARTY ……………………….... RESPONDENTS
  3. INEC

WITNESS STATEMENT ON OATH OF CHIEF BEN OKAGBUE

I, Chief Ben Okagbue, Male, Adult, Business man and Nigerian Citizen of no. 15 Manson Lodge in Asaba North Senatorial District of Delta State do make oath and state as follows:

  1. That I am the 1st Respondent in this Petition and by virtue of which I am conversant with the facts of this case.
  2. That I am the Senatorial candidate of Unity Congress Party in the re-run election conducted on Saturday the 24th day of March 2011 for the Asaba North Senatorial District, where of I was declared the winner with 15,000 votes out of the 25,500 lawful votes cast at the election, a copy of the Return Certificate is hereby attached and marked EXHIBIT A.
  3. That the election was peaceful in a free and fair atmosphere.
  4. That there was total compliance with the Electoral Act 2010 on the conduct of election in Nigeria.
  5. That the election was not marred with irregularities of any kind including the snatching of ballot boxes nor threating.
  6. That I was never indicted by the Economic and Financial Crimes Commission on any financial misappropriation of any kind nor at any time whatsoever.
  7. That I was also never convicted by the High Court of Asaba for the offence of receiving stolen property nor any other offence by any Court whatsoever.
  8. That I pray this Honourable Tribunal to dismiss or strike out the petition for lack of merit as it is made in bad faith.
  9. That I depose to this affidavit in good faith believing its content to be true and correct and in accordance with the Oaths Act LFN 2004.

………………………………
Deponent


Sworn to at the National and State Houses
of Assembly Election Tribunal Registry,
This 27th day of March 2011.

BEFORE ME

_____________________
COMMISSIONER OF OATHS